Graphical Reporting in Italian Annual Reports during the Financial Crisis: Impression Management or Incremental Information?

Anteprima

This paper investigates whether, before and during the global financial crisis, Italian firms have used financial key performance indicators graphs in the annual reports as impression management tools, to portray a more favourable picture of the firm’s performance than is warranted. This study shows that, during the financial crisis, firms have increased the number of graphs and decreased favourable distortions, although graphs continued to be designed inaccurately. The findings could reflect an increased public scrutiny on the firm’s performance, during the financial crisis. As a theoretical implication, this paper contributes to the existent financial reporting literature by showing that graphs are not necessarily used in line with an agency theory-based impression management, which is the dominant perspective to explain the graphs’ usage in the annual reports during periods of performance upturn. Moreover, it shows that the institutional context can affect voluntary disclosure practices at a firm-level. As a practical implication, this study suggests to annual reports’ readers not to necessarily consider managers as self-serving preparers in their graphical reporting strategies. The study also suggests accounting associations, audit firms and other regulatory bodies to create a set of guidelines for a correct graph’s use and design.

_

Keywords: Financial crisis, financial key performance indicators graphs, impression management, incremental information

Bibliografia
  1. Aerts W. (2001), Inertia in the attributional content of annual accounting narratives, European accounting review, 10 (1), pp. 3-32,, DOI:10.1080/09638180122562
  2. Aerts W. (2005), Picking up the pieces: impression management in the retrospective attributional framing of accounting outcomes, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 30 (6), pp. 493-517,,DOI:10.1016/j.aos.2004.07.001
  3. Ashforth B.E. and Gibbs B.W. (1990), The double-edge of organizational legitimation, Organization science, 1 (2), pp. 177-194,, DOI:10.1287/orsc.1.2.177
  4. Barniv R., Myring M.J. and Thomas W.B. (2005), The Association between the Legal and Financial Reporting Environments and Forecast Performance of Individual Analysts, Contemporary Accounting Research, 22 (4), pp. 727-758,, DOI:10.1506/75CE-HAT9-RH17-LAD7
  5. Barth M.E. and Landsman W.R. (2010), How did financial reporting contribute to the financial crisis?, European Accounting Review, 19 (3), pp. 399-423,, DOI:10.1080/09638180.2010.498619
  6. Barton J. and Mercer M. (2005), To blame or not to blame: Analysts’ reactions to external explanations for poor financial performance, Journal of accounting and economics, 39 (3), pp. 509-533,,DOI:10.1016/j.jacceco.2005.04.006
  7. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J (1992a), The use and abuse of graph sinannual reports: theoretical framework and empirical study, Accounting and Business Research, 22 (88), pp.291-303,, doi:10.1080/00014788.1992.9729446
  8. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (1992b), The communication of information using graphs in corporate annual reports, Certified Accountants Educational Trust, London.
  9. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (1997), A Comparitive Study of the Use of Financial Graphs in the Corporate Annual Reports of Major US and UK Companies, Journal of International Financial Management & Accounting, 8 (1), pp. 33-68,, DOI:10.1111/1467-646X.00016
  10. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (2000a), Changing graph use in corporate annual reports: A time-series analysis, Contemporary Accounting Research, 17 (2), pp. 213-226,, DOI:10.1506/AAT8-3CGL-3J94-PH4F
  11. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (2000b), Impression management: the case of inter–country financial graphs, Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 9 (2), pp. 159-83,, DOI:10.1016/S1061-9518(00)00030-6
  12. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (2001), A six-country comparison of the use of graphs in annual reports, International Journal of Accounting, 36 (2), pp. 195-222,, DOI:10.1016/S0020-7063(01)00094-2
  13. Beattie V.A. and Jones M.J. (2008), Corporate reporting using graphs: a review and synthesis, Journal of Accounting Literature, 27, pp. 71-110.
  14. Beattie V.A., Dhanani A. and Jones M.J. (2008), Investigating Presentational Change in UK Annual Reports A Longitudinal Perspective, Journal of Business Communication, 45 (2), pp. 181-222,,DOI:10.1177/002194360731399
  15. Bini L., Dainelli F. and Giunta F. (2011), Country effects on European mandatory disclosure of financial key performance indicators, Financial Reporting, 1, pp. 73-91,, DOI:10.3280/FR2011-001004
  16. Borsa Italiana (2006), Capitalizzazione delle società quotate al 29 dicembre 2006, http://www.borsaitaliana.it/borsaitaliana/statistiche/statistichestoriche/capitalizzazioni/2006/dicembre/capitalizzazionedellesocietaquotate_pdf.htm.
  17. Borsa Italiana (2007), Capitalizzazione delle società quotate al 28 dicembre 2007, http://www.borsaitaliana.it/borsaitaliana/statistiche/statistichestoriche/capitaliz zazioni/2007/200712/capitalizzazionedellesocietaquotate_pdf.htm.
  18. Borsa Italiana (2008), Capitalizzazione delle società quotate al 30 dicembre 2008, http://www.borsaitaliana.it/borsaitaliana/statistiche/statistichestoriche/capitalizzazioni/2008/200812/capitalizzazionedellesocietaquotate_pdf.htm.
  19. Borsa Italiana (2009), Capitalizzazione delle società quotate al 30 dicembre 2009, http://www.borsaitaliana.it/borsaitaliana/statistiche/statistichestoriche/capitalizzazioni/2009/200912/capitalizzazionedellesocietaquotate_pdf.htm.
  20. Borsa Italiana (2015), Blue Chip, http://www.borsaitaliana.it/azioni/mercati/mta/segmento-blue-chip.en.htm.
  21. Brammer S. and Millington A. (2005), Corporate reputation and philanthropy: An empirical analysis, Journal of Business Ethics, 61 (1), pp. 29-44,, DOI:10.1007/s10551-005-7443-4
  22. Brunello G., Graziano C. and Parigi B.M. (2003), CEO turnover in insiderdominated boards: The Italian case, Journal of Banking & Finance, 27 (6), pp. 1027-1051,, DOI:10.1016/S0378-4266(02)00244-3
  23. Carter S.M. and Dukerich J.M. (1998), Corporate responses to changes in reputation, Corporate Reputation Review, 1 (3), pp.250-270, doi:10.1057/palgrave.crr.1540047
  24. Cassar G. (2001), Self-serving behaviour and the voluntary disclosure of capital market performance, Accounting Research Journal, 14 (2), pp. 126-137.
  25. Chekkar‐Mansouri R., Gillet-Monjarret C. and Martinez I. (2013), Improving Performance Understanding with Visual Presentations: An Experimental Study (March 1, 2013), Working Paper,,DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2226930
  26. Cho C.H., Michelon G. and Patten D. (2012a), Enhancement and obfuscation through the use of graphs in sustainability reports: An international comparison, Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal, 3 (1), pp. 74-88,, DOI:10.1108/20408021211223561
  27. Cho C.H., Michelon G. and Patten D.M. (2012b), Impression management in sustainability reports: An empirical investigation of the use of graphs, Accounting and the Public Interest, 12 (1), pp. 16-37,,DOI:10.2308/apin-10249
  28. Clarke T. (2007), International corporate governance: A comparative approach. (London: Routledge).
  29. Courtis J.K. (1997), Corporate Annual Report Graphical Communication in Hong Kong: Effective or Misleading?, Journal of Business Communication, 34 (3), pp. 269-284,,DOI:10.1177/002194369703400304
  30. D’Aveni R.A. and MacMillan I.C. (1990), Crisis and the content of managerial communications: A study of the focus of attention of top managers in surviving and failing firms, Administrative Science Quarterly, pp. 634-657,, DOI:10.2307/2393512
  31. Davidson W.N., Jiraporn P., Kim Y.S. and Nemec C. (2004), Earnings management following duality-creating successions: Ethnostatistics, impression management, and agency theory, Academy of management journal, 47 (2), pp. 267-275,, DOI:10.2307/20159577
  32. Davis L.R. (1989), Report format and the decision maker’s task: An experimental investigation, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 14 (5-6), pp. 495-508,, DOI:10.1016/0361-3682(89)90014-7
  33. Dilla W.N. and Janvrin D.J. (2010), Voluntary Disclosure in Annual Reports: The Association between Magnitude and Direction of Change in Corporate Financial Performance and Graph Use, Accounting Horizons, 24 (2), pp. 257-278,, DOI:10.2308/acch.2010.24.2.257
  34. Dilla W.N., Janvrin D.J. and Jeffrey C. (2013), The impact of graphical displays of pro forma earnings information on professional and nonprofessional investors’ earnings judgments, Behavioral Research in Accounting, 25 (1), pp. 37-60,, DOI:10.2308/bria-50289
  35. Elliott W.B. (2006), Are investors influenced by pro forma emphasis and reconciliations in earnings announcements?, The Accounting Review, 81 (1), pp. 113-133,, DOI:10.2308/accr.2006.81.1.113
  36. Frownfelter C. and Fulkerson C. (1998), Linking the incidence and quality of graphics in annual reports to corporate performance: An international comparison, Advances in Accounting Information Systems, 6, pp. 129-151.
  37. Girella L. and Zambon S. (2013), Regulating through the” Logic of Appropriateness” and the” Rhetoric of the Expert”: The Role of Consultants in the Case of Intangibles Reporting in Germany, Financial reporting, 3-4, pp. 75-109,, DOI:10.3280/FR2013-003005
  38. Gujarati D. (2003), Basic econometrics. (New York: McGraw Hill).
  39. Healy P.M. and Palepu K.G. (2001), Information asymmetry, corporate disclosure, and the capital markets: A review of the empirical disclosure literature, Journal of accounting and economics, 31 (1), pp. 405-440,,DOI:10.1016/S0165-4101(01)00018-0
  40. Hill, Y.W. and Milner, M. (2003), Guidelines for graphical displays in financial reporting. Accounting Education, 12 (2), pp. 135-157,, DOI:10.1080/0963928032000091747
  41. Ianniello G. (2009), The use of graphs in annual reports of major Italian companies, International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation, 5 (4), pp. 442-462,,DOI:10.1504/IJAAPE.2009.027881
  42. Inchausti B.G. (1997), The influence of company characteristics and accounting regulation on information disclosed by Spanish firms, European Accounting Review, 6 (1), pp. 45-68,,DOI:10.1080/096381897336863
  43. International Accounting Standards Board (1989), Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements, April.
  44. ISTAT (2009), Rapporto Annuale – La situazione del Paese nel 2009, http://www3.istat.it/dati/catalogo/20100526_00/Avvio2009.pdf.
  45. ISTAT (2010), Conti Economici Nazionali, http://www.istat.it/it/archivio/99946.
  46. Johnson J., Rice R. and Roemmich R. (1980), Pictures that lie: the abuse of graphs in annual reports, Management Accounting, October, pp. 50-56.
  47. Keusch T., Bollen L.H. and Hassink H.F. (2012), Self-serving bias in annual report narratives: An empirical analysis of the impact of economic crises, European Accounting Review, 21 (3), pp. 623-648,,DOI:10.1080/09638180.2011.641729
  48. La Porta R., Lopez‐de‐Silanes F. and Shleifer A. (1999), Corporate ownership around the world, The Journal of Finance, 54 (2), pp. 471-517,, DOI:10.1111/0022-1082.00115
  49. La Porta R., Lopez-de-Silanes F., Shleifer A. and Vishny R. (2002), Investor protection and corporate valuation, Journal of Finance, 57 (3), pp. 1147-1170,, DOI:10.1111/1540-6261.00457
  50. Leuz C., Nanda D. and Wysocki P.D. (2003), Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison, Journal of Financial Economics, 69 (3), pp. 505-527,, DOI:10.1016/S0304-405X(03)00121-1
  51. Mather D., Mather P. and Ramsay A. (2005), An investigation into the measurement of graph distortion in financial reports, Accounting and Business Research, 35 (2), pp. 147-159,,DOI:10.1080/00014788.2005.9729670
  52. Mather P., Ramsay A. and Serry A. (1996), The use and representational faithfulness of graphs in annual reports: Australian evidence, Australian Accounting Review, 6 (2), pp. 56-63,, DOI:10.1111/j.1835-2561.1996.tb00017.x
  53. Melis A. (2000), Corporate governance in Italy, Corporate Governance: An International Review, 8 (4), pp. 347-355,, DOI:10.1111/1467-8683.00213
  54. Merkl-Davies D. and Brennan N. (2007), Discretionary disclosure strategies in corporate narratives: Incremental information or impression management, Journal of Accounting Literature, 26, pp. 116-196. Merkl-Davies D.M. and Brennan N.M. (2011), A conceptual framework of impression management: new insights from psychology, sociology and critical perspectives, Accounting and Business Research, 41 (5), pp. 415-437,, DOI:10.1080/00014788.2011.574222
  55. Merkl-Davies D.M., Brennan N.M. and McLeay S.J. (2011), Impression management and retrospective sense-making in corporate narratives: A social psychology perspective, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 24 (3), pp. 315-344,, DOI:10.1108/09513571111124036
  56. Mia P. and Al-Mamun A. (2014), Corporate social disclosure during the global financial crisis, International Journal of Economics and Finance, 3 (6), pp. 174-187,, DOI:10.5539/ijef.v3n6p174
  57. Michelon G. (2012), Impression management and legitimacy strategies: The BP case, Financial Reporting, 4, pp. 35-64,, DOI:10.3280/FR2012-004004
  58. Muino F. and Trombetta M. (2009), Does graph disclosure bias reduce the cost of equity capital?, Accounting and Business Research, 39 (2), pp. 83-102,, DOI:10.1080/00014788.2009.9663351
  59. Pagano M., Panetta F. and Zingales A.L. (1998), Why Do Companies Go Public? An Empirical Analysis, The Journal of Finance, 53, pp. 27-64,, DOI:10.1111/0022-1082.25448
  60. Patelli L. and Pedrini M. (2013), Is the optimism in CEO’s letters to shareholders sincere? Impression management versus communicative action during the economic crisis, Journal of Business Ethics, pp. 1-16,, DOI:10.1007/s10551-013-1855-3
  61. Powell T.C. (1996), Research Notes and Communications. How Much does Industry Matter? An Alternative Empirical Test, Strategic Management Journal, 17 (4), pp. 323-334,, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199604)17:4%3C323::AIDSMJ803%3E3.0.CO;2-5
  62. Rowbottom N. and Lymer A. (2010), Exploring the use and users of narrative reporting in the online annual report, Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 11 (2), pp. 90-108,,DOI:10.1108/09675421011069487
  63. Schultz F. and Raupp J. (2010), The social construction of crises in governmental and corporate communications: An inter-organizational and inter-systemic analysis, Public Relations Review, 36 (2), pp. 112-119,, DOI:10.1016/j.pubrev.2009.11.002
  64. Stanton P. and Stanton J. (2002), Corporate annual reports: research perspectives used, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 15 (4), pp. 478-500,, DOI:10.1108/09513570210440568
  65. Staw B.M., Sandelands L.E. and Dutton J.E. (1981), Threat-rigidity effects in organizational behavior: A multilevel analysis, Administrative science quarterly, 26 (4), pp. 501-524,, DOI:10.2307/2392337
  66. Steinbart P.J. (1989), The auditor’s responsibility for the accuracy of graphs in annual reports: some evidence of the need for additional guidance, Accounting Horizons, 3 (3), pp. 60-70.
  67. Taylor B.G. and Anderson L.K. (1986), Misleading graphs: guidelines for the accountant, Journal of Accountancy, 162, pp. 126-135.
  68. Tufte E.R. (1983), The visual display of quantitative information. (Cheshire: Graphics Press). Vanstraelen A., Zarzeski M.T. and Robb S.W. (2003), Corporate nonfinancial disclosure practices and financial analyst forecast ability across three European countries, Journal of International Financial Management & Accounting, 14 (3), pp. 249-278,, DOI:10.1111/1467-646X.00098
  69. Vessey I. (1991), Cognitive Fit: A Theory‐Based Analysis of the Graphs Versus Tables Literature, Decision Sciences, 22.2, pp. 219-240,, DOI:10.1111/j.1540-5915.1991.tb00344.x
  70. Volmer F.G. (1992), Effect of graphical presentations on insights into a company’s financial position: an innovative educational approach to communicating financial information in financial reporting, Accounting Education, 1 (2), pp. 151-170,, DOI:10.1080/09639289200000025
  71. Watson A., Shrives P. and Marston C. (2002), Voluntary disclosure of accounting ratios in the UK, The British Accounting Review, 34 (4), pp. 289-313,, DOI:10.1006/bare.2002.0213
  72. Watts R.L. and Zimmerman J.L. (1990), Positive Accounting Theory: A Ten Year Perspective, The Accounting Review, 65 (1), pp. 131-156.
  73. Yeoh P. (2010), Narrative reporting: the UK experience, International Journal of Law and Management, 52 (3), pp. 211-231,, DOI:10.1108/17542431011044652
  74. Yuthas K., Rogers R. and Dillard J.F. (2002), Communicative action and corporate annual reports, Journal of Business Ethics, 41 (1-2), pp. 141-157,, DOI:10.1023/A:1021314626311